Attorney
Jeffrey I. Carton
Partner
About
Jeffrey I. Carton is a partner at Denlea & Carton LLP and an experienced civil litigator whose practice spans complex commercial disputes, consumer class actions, personal injury, intellectual property, sports, media and entertainment, and maritime matters. He represents both plaintiffs and defendants and has handled matters through trial, arbitration, appeals, and federal and state court proceedings. His Verified Matters reflect that range of experience, including nationwide consumer class actions, business ownership and contract disputes, franchise and trademark litigation, restrictive covenants, sports organizations, serious injury claims, and commercial arbitration. Documented results include multimillion-dollar class settlements, a $4.5 million gross jury verdict, a $2.48 million arbitration award later confirmed by the court, preliminary-injunction relief, and dismissals obtained for organizational clients. Carton began his legal career at Cravath, Swaine & Moore and is a graduate of Columbia Law School and Dartmouth College.
Practice Areas
- Admiralty and Maritime Law
- Appellate Litigation
- Arbitration
- Commercial Law
- Business Litigation
- Business Organizations Law
- Class Action
- Civil Contract Law
- Communications and Media
- Commercial and Trade Law
- Contract Law
- Consumer Protection Law
- Corporate Law
- Intellectual Property Law
- Law of Obligations
- Personal Injury and Tort Law
- Sports Law
- Telecommunications, Media, and Entertainment Law
- Workplace Injury
- Wrongful Death
- Construction Accident
Verified Case Results
- $2.9 Million Tom’s of Maine Toothpaste Class Action Settlement · $2.9 million nationwide Tom’s of Maine toothpaste class action settlement granted final approval.
- Chevrolet Dealership Property Notice of Pendency Cancellation Affirmed on Appeal · Secured cancellation of a notice of pendency on Chevrolet dealership property; New York appellate court affirmed with costs.
- Michael Barisone vs USEF: Federal Lawsuit Dismissed · Obtained dismissal of all claims against USEF and entry of judgment in its favor; plaintiff subsequently appealed.
- Ricardo Moncada v. Nuna Baby Essentials, Inc. · Motion to dismiss denied; consumer fraud claims proceed
- Shleppers LLC Ownership Dispute: Injunction Denied - Carton · Preliminary injunction and $763,473 prejudgment attachment request against the clients denied in full.
- TZ Vista LLC Dispute: Buy-Sell Provision Enforced - Carton · Trial court upheld Operating Agreement’s buy/sell provision in case of membership deadlock
- Fresh & Co Preliminary Injunction Against Former Franchisee · Preliminary injunction obtained prohibiting the defendants from operating the Yonkers location as a Fresh & Co restaurant, using Fresh & Co trade names, trademarks, service marks and trade dress, violating specified non-compete obligations, and using or disclosing Fresh & Co confidential information.
- Elite Model Management Restrictive-Covenant Injunction Defeated - Carton · Preliminary-injunction and non-solicitation relief defeated/vacated; defendants awarded $811,881.21 in costs and attorneys' fees.
- Ford F-Series Door Latch Class Action: $5.3M Settlement - Carton · $5.3 million court-approved nationwide class action settlement resolving Ford F-Series door latch claims.
- Tarik Sheppard v. United States Tennis Association · Appeal won; negligent hiring and training claim dismissed
- Mercedes-Benz Dealership Arbitration: $2.48M Award Confirmed - Carton · The court confirmed the $2.48 million arbitration award, which was satisfied in full, along with arbitration expenses, post-award interest, and costs.
- Beggin’ Strips Consumer Deception Class Action · Court denied Purina’s motion to dismiss the core GBL §349 deceptive-practices claim; only website representations were dismissed.
- RPI Electrical Burn Injury: $4.5M Jury Verdict Affirmed - Carton · $4.5 million gross jury verdict; adjusted judgment affirmed on appeal, subject to 20% plaintiff comparative fault.
- Construction Accident Settlement for Electrician · $4 million settlement
Background
Education
- Dartmouth College
- Columbia Law School
Bar admissions
- New York · 2442622
- Connecticut · 19966
- U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York
- U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
- U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York
- U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut
- United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
- United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
- United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
- United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
- Supreme Court of the United States
Awards
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2025
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2024
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2023
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2022
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2021
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2020
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2019
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2014
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2013
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2012
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2011
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2010
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2009
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2008
- Super Lawyers Top 25: Westchester County Super Lawyers Top List · Super Lawyers · 2007