Verified Matter
TZ Vista LLC Business Partner Dispute Operating Agreement’s Buy/Sell Provision Enforced
Trial court upheld Operating Agreement’s buy/sell provision in case of membership deadlock
Denlea & Carton LLP represented TZ Vista LLC, DCAK-MSA Architecture & Engineering, PC, Drazen Cackovic, and Julia Khomut in a dispute among members of a closely held LLC formed to develop Hudson River real estate in Nyack, New York. The dispute arose from a breakdown between the managing members over the development venture and involved enforcement of the LLC operating agreement, a contractual option requiring transfer of “Parcel 7,” management deadlock, and the opposing member’s effort to dissolve the company. The trial court granted summary judgment requiring specific performance and conveyance of Parcel 7 and rejected the judicial-dissolution claim. Later proceedings enforced the operating agreement’s buy-sell mechanism for resolving member deadlock, and in February 2025 the Appellate Division, Second Department affirmed the specific-performance and dissolution rulings with costs.
Result
- Outcome
- Appeal Won
- Short result
- Trial court upheld Operating Agreement’s buy/sell provision in case of membership deadlock
- Remedy
- Specific Performance; Property Conveyance; Civil Contempt; Contractual Buyout Enforcement; Attorney Fees
- Year
- 2025
- Published
- 2026-10-01
Supporting sources
- Official New York Courts — January 3, 2022 Supreme Court decision granting plaintiffs partial summary judgment and specific performance: · Court opinion
- Official New York Courts — March 30, 2023 decision granting plaintiffs’ civil-contempt motion, denying a stay pending appeal, and directing compliance with the specific-performance judgment: · Court opinion
- Official New York Courts — October 28, 2024 decision enforcing the operating agreement’s buy-sell mechanism and addressing the parties’ management deadlock: · Court opinion
- Official New York State Law Reporting Bureau — February 5, 2025 Appellate Division decision affirming the order with costs · Court opinion
- Rockland County Business Journal - Legal Battle Draws On Over Who Will Own Gedney Street Project · News / public announcement
- RCBizJournal RCBJ — Land Use Approvals Lapse on Stalled Gedney Street Project · Court opinion
- NY Business Divorce New York Business Divorce — Analysis of TZ Vista v. Helmer · Court opinion
- New York CPLR · 3212 · Statute / rule
- New York Limited Liability Company Law · § 702 · Statute / rule
- New York Judiciary Law · § 753 · Statute / rule
- New York Judiciary Law · § 773 · Statute / rule
- New York CPLR · 5519(c) · Statute / rule